Skip to content

Guide · 3 min read

Sharp and soft bookmakers: who sets the right prices?

BookmakersCorners over 9.5

Premier League

LiverpoolvsArsenal

Pinnacle (sharp)1.96

Fair odds without margin2.00

bet365 (soft)2.10

Value+5%

Figure 23. Pinnacle gives 1.96 on over 9.5 corners. Without the margin, that is fair odds of 2.00. bet365 gives 2.10 on the same bet. That is 5% above fair, so it is a value bet.Example in the VPS Betting app · not current odds

Short answer

Sharp bookmakers have low margins, accept big stakes from professional bettors and move the price after them. So their odds are close to the real chance. Soft bookmakers target recreational bettors, have higher margins and often limit winners. Example: Pinnacle gives 1.96 on over 9.5 corners, which is fair odds of 2.00. When bet365 still gives 2.10, that is 5% above fair. Value bettors use sharp prices to find the fair odds and bet at soft bookmakers when they are behind.

What makes a bookmaker sharp?

A sharp bookmaker lives on volume rather than a high margin. It adds little to the odds, accepts big stakes and welcomes professional bettors. When sharp money comes in on one side, it moves the price. Over time the price becomes a good estimate of the real probability.

Internationally, Pinnacle and betting exchanges such as Betfair are often used as a reference, because their prices are shaped by many sharp bettors. Always check that a bookmaker is licensed in your country before you bet there yourself.

What is typical of a soft bookmaker?

A soft bookmaker targets recreational bettors with bonuses, lots of special markets and an easy app. The margin is usually higher, especially on special markets. Many soft bookmakers follow the market rather than set the price themselves, and they limit customers who win over time.

Because they follow the market, their price can be a moment behind when new information arrives or a sharp bookmaker moves. Those are the moments value bettors look for.

Example: the same match at two bookmakers

Take over/under 9.5 corners in Liverpool–Arsenal. Pinnacle, which is sharp, gives 1.96 on both. That equals 51.02% + 51.02% = 102.04%, a margin of about 2%. Remove the margin and the fair odds are 2.00 on each side, which is 50%.

bet365, which is soft, normally gives 1.90 on both, a margin of about 5.3%. After some news, bet365 has not yet moved its price on over 9.5 corners and gives 2.10. Compared with the fair odds of 2.00, that is a value bet: 2.10 ÷ 2.00 − 1 = +5%.

Over/under 9.5 corners in Liverpool–Arsenal (example figures)
Liverpool–ArsenalPinnacle (sharp)bet365 (soft)Fair (no margin)
Over 9.5 corners1.962.102.00
Under 9.5 corners1.961.752.00
Sum of probabilities102.04%104.76%100%

How to use the difference

Work out the fair odds from the sharpest prices by removing the margin. Compare them with the odds the other bookmakers offer. When a bookmaker gives more than the fair odds, the bet has positive expected value.

After kick-off you can measure whether you got a good price by comparing your odds with the sharp closing odds. That is called closing line value, and it is one of the best signs that your method works.

Sharp does not mean perfect

Sharp prices can be wrong too, especially in small leagues and in markets with little money. Early prices are less certain than the price just before kick-off. So use sharp prices as the best reference available, not as the answer key.

Always compare the same market, the same line and the same time. A price on over 9.5 corners cannot be compared with over 10.5, and a price from yesterday cannot be compared with a price today.

About this guide

The odds in the example are hypothetical and chosen to make the calculation easy to follow. They do not show current prices at specific bookmakers.

Read next

Frequently asked questions

What is a sharp bookmaker?

A bookmaker with a low margin that accepts big stakes from professional bettors and moves the price after them. Its odds are therefore close to the real chance, for example 1.96 on both sides of a 50/50 market.

Is bet365 a soft bookmaker?

bet365 is usually seen as soft: it targets recreational bettors, has a higher margin than the sharpest markets and limits customers who win over time.

Why do value bettors use sharp prices?

Because sharp prices are the best available estimate of the real probability. Without the margin they give the fair odds that other bookmakers’ prices can be compared with.

Find value bets automatically

VPS Betting compares the odds at your bookmakers with the sharp market and shows the bets with positive expected value.

See plans and free trial

Bet responsibly

Only bet if you are of legal gambling age in your country, and only with bookmakers licensed there. Only bet money you can afford to lose. Use the deposit limits and self-exclusion tools available where you live, and contact a support service in your country if betting stops being fun.